Allegations of a sex scandal involving a high-profile BBC presenter have escalated into a war between two of the UK’s leading news publishers.
This episode can now only result with either News UK-owned The Sun or the BBC having their credibility severely diminished.
The Sun reported on Saturday that an unnamed high-profile BBC presenter had paid a young person for sexually explicit images over a period of three years from the age of 17 onwards.
The Sun said its story was based on sworn affadavits from the young person’s parents and it said that the parents’ initial complaint made to the BBC more than a month ago had been ignored. The parents say the money paid to their child, some £35,000, has been used to fuel a crack cocaine habit.
The lawyer wrote: “For the avoidance of doubt, nothing inappropriate or unlawful has taken place between our client and the BBC personality and the allegations reported in the Sun newspaper are rubbish.
“Nobody from the Sun newspaper appears to have made any attempt to contact our client prior to the publication of the allegations on Friday 6 July.”
The lawyer said the young person also contacted The Sun via Whatsapp on Friday night, the eve of publication, to deny the claims.
The Sun reports that the young person’s stepfather told the BBC in detail about the allegations in May, and that the BBC’s assertion that Saturday’s Sun story involved new allegations (which led to the presenter’s suspension) was a lie.
In a leader column today headlined: “BBC in dock”, The Sun stood by its reporting of the affair and said: “The BBC has massive questions to answer over its failure to act immediately over the scandal involving one of its top stars – and why it kept the presenter on air.”
The Daily Mail, meanwhile, reports that when it asked 291 people around the UK to name the BBC presenter involved in The Sun story, 49 were able to name the individual who it says is at the centre of the allegations (one in six). It said a further 21 named a presenter who is not involved in the affair.
All mainstream news publishers have thus far avoided naming the presenter concerned, mainly because of the defamation risk. Only The Sun has seen any evidence and any publisher would have to be confident they could prove the deeply damaging allegations in court before they could risk running them.
It has now effectively staked its reputation on the parents’ testimony being true. If the story turns out to be “rubbish” as the young person’s lawyer claims, then questions will be asked about why The Sun ran the story at all. It would be a seismic blow to the paper’s reputation.
Similarly, if The Sun story turns out to be substantially true, the BBC – the biggest news brand in the UK, and biggest English-speaking news service in the world – will face a major crisis. It will have to explain why the initial complaint was not acted upon and why it published a story last night effectively dismissing The Sun’s claims.
Update 12/7/23: In a surprising twist the BBC has published new allegations that the presenter in question was said to have been in contact with a person in their early 20s via a dating app and then sent them abusive messages. BBC journalists contacted the presenter in question and these new developments led last night’s 10pm news bulletin.
Meanwhile, The Sun today has new revelations of a lockdown-breaking meet up in February 2021 between the presenter and a 23-year-old.
These latest developments suggest the journalism of The Sun and BBC could both emerge strongly from this affair. Though with allegations mounting, the BBC will still have much to answer for at a corporate level and the case against the presenter themselves is beginning to look damning.
Email firstname.lastname@example.org to point out mistakes, provide story tips or send in a letter for publication on our "Letters Page" blog