The Scottish Culture Secretary has raised fears that STV’s news restructure, which has put 59 jobs at risk, will “diminish the range of voices and perspective available to audiences”, especially in local news.
Fiona Hyslop (pictured) wrote an open letter to Ofcom suggesting the broadcast regulator should consider a review of the plurality and quality of Scottish news provision in the near future.
- May 7, 2020
- September 3, 2019
- January 9, 2019
It will also close loss-making TV channel STV2 at the end of June, putting a a further 25 jobs at risk of redundancy as investment in content shifts to STV and online streaming service STV Player.
In a letter to Ofcom Scotland director Glenn Preston, Hyslop raised particular concerns over the loss of STV2 programme STV News Tonight, which airs each weeknight at 7pm and covers Scottish, UK and international news from a Scottish perspective.
STV News Tonight had an average audience of 4,000 viewers throughout 2017, compared to between 300,000 and 350,000 for the main channel’s 6pm bulletin STV News.
Scotland Tonight, the half-hourly current news and current affairs programme which airs on STV on Monday to Thursday evenings, will be unaffected by the changes.
Hyslop, an SNP MSP, wrote: “I wish to note regret at the loss, in STV News Tonight, of a distinctive aspect of news provision in Scotland – one which diminishes the range of voices and perspectives available to audiences.
“We are also concerned about the potential effect of these developments on the quality of coverage of Scottish news received by audiences in Scotland.
“The Scottish Government supports Ofcom’s view that plurality matters and an important aspect of achieving this is ensuring a diversity of viewpoints are available and consumed across and within the media.
“In view of the range of current and anticipated developments, there may be a case for reviewing the plurality and quality of news provision in Scotland at an appropriate point in the near future to ensure that audiences in Scotland have access to a continuing diversity of viewpoints and high-quality programmes.”
As part of the closure of STV2, the broadcaster has agreed to sell its local TV assets to That’s Media, which has a number of local stations in England.
Hyslop asked Ofcom for confirmation as to whether their consent was obtained before the announcement of the planned transfer of the STV2 licences.
She added: “Secondly, I assume that the commercial terms agreed with That’s Media Group oblige them to fulfil the commitments in all five local digital television programme service licences in full, including those for local news (and the higher level of local news commitments for Glasgow and Edinburgh), and we would welcome confirmation from Ofcom that the proposed new holder is aware of these terms and that they are an appropriate licensee.”
An STV spokesperson said: “The decision to close STV2 has been made on a commercial basis. STV is not proposing any changes to our Channel 3 licence commitments, with STV News continuing to provide uniquely local programmes across Scotland.
“The future changes to STV News announced last week will result in a more comprehensive news service from STV. We will continue to deliver high-quality broadcast news defined by its localness and invest in our digital news, thereby increasing choice for audiences across all platforms.”
An Ofcom spokesperson said: “We are considering the matters raised in the Scottish Culture Secretary’s letter, and we will discuss her concerns in detail at our forthcoming meeting.”
Yesterday STV chief executive Simon Pitts told the Sunday Times the plans were not “set in stone”.
He said: “I’d be surprised if the plan is exactly the same in six weeks’ time when we’ve had our formal discussions with our teams. We will think hard about what they are saying, and if that involves making changes to improve the overall plan then we’ll consider that.”
He added: “I’m not saying it is set in stone to the final tee.”
Staff could strike over the proposals within the next month after chapel members from the National Union of Journalists voted unanimously to ballot for industrial action.
Talks continue between STV management, the NUJ and media union BECTU, which represents technical staff.
Picture: Reuters/Yves Herman