Fighting for quality news media in the digital age.

  1. Publishers
  2. Digital Journalism
July 4, 2016updated 11 Jul 2016 3:01pm

Telegraph pulls article that claims Theresa May is ‘terrible Home Secretary’

By Freddy Mayhew

The Telegraph has pulled a comment piece describing Theresa May as a “terrible Home Secretary” as she fights to become leader of the Conservatives and the next Prime Minister.

The piece was published on Friday in the News section of telegraph.co.uk but has since been taken down from the website.

It was written by regular freelance contributor Jonathan Foreman, who says the article was pulled after May’s campaign team leaned on editors at the national daily.

He told Press Gazette: “The Telegraph told me they were delighted with my piece but had made an error in posting it up without my byline on it, making it look like a leader column.

“I said that’s fine, just put my byline on it and republish it. But then I was told it was a technical glitch. Then later they said they had been lent on.”

In his article, still available in a cached view online, Foreman compares May to conniving Game of Thrones character Cersei Lannister saying: “No one who challenges her survives undamaged”.

Theresa May Telegraph story CROPPED

Screen grab of the cached telegraph.co.uk article

He also says her tenure as Home Secretary “has been little better than disastrous” and that it was “as if the icy Home Secretary had a dark magic that warded off all critical scrutiny” after May avoided a rap over failing to deliver on a Tory pledge to reduce the number of migrants into the UK.

Claiming the Maidenhead MP is a “great self-promoter”, Foreman added: “There’s a vast gulf between being effective in office, and being effective at promoting yourself; it’s not one that Theresa May has yet crossed.”

A poll run alongside the piece asked readers “Do you want Theresa May to be Prime Minister?” with 13 per cent saying “yes” and 87 per cent saying “no”.

Foreman added: “It’s more of a reflection on the newspaper than the politicians, who are always trying to control things to some extent. For a big paper to give in like that is really shocking.”

A spokesperson for the Telegraph declined to comment. Theresa May’s office has been approached for comment.

Topics in this article :

Email pged@pressgazette.co.uk to point out mistakes, provide story tips or send in a letter for publication on our "Letters Page" blog

Websites in our network