News agency gets name ban lifted

Magistrates overturned a Section 39 Order within six hours of making it – after a successful challenge by a news agency.

bench had banned the naming of a 13-month-old girl who was allegedly
abandoned in a busy town by a man accused of being drunk.

The anonymity order was imposed automatically by the magistrates because the girl was a juvenile.

Paul Henry Smith appeared at East Berkshire Magistrates’ Court accused of abandoning baby Lily.

reporter Tom Brooke-Taylor, working for Reading-based INS News Group,
said as soon as Smith was arraigned, the court clerk advised
magistrates to impose a Section 39 Order.

When Brooke-Taylor said INS wanted to challenge the order, the clerk said he would have to make full representations in writing.

the end of the day’s proceedings, magistrates considered a faxed letter
sent to the court by INS editor Neil Hyde, arguing that the child was
too young to be affected by identification.

However Brooke-Taylor was told he would have to produce the “relevant authorities for this argument”.

news agency faxed a letter to the court, listing previous similar cases
where Section 39 Orders had been lifted and giving the stated reasons.
This was also not considered good enough.

Finally, a document on
reporting restrictions, supported by the Newspaper Society, was
produced by court staff from their office above the court. Magistrate
Sheila McLoughlin then lifted the order.

No comments to display

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *