Fighting for quality news media in the digital age.

Independent says readers ‘often prefer’ stories on new AI ‘Bulletin’ to human-written versions

Independent UK editor Chloe Hubbard said the new AI-written service "works commercially".

By Bron Maher

The Independent’s UK editor has said stories on its new AI-written summarisation service, Bulletin, often outperform the human-written content on which they are based.

The service, which uses Google’s Gemini to rewrite regular Independent stories into five to ten bullet points, officially launched on Wednesday following a soft launch over recent weeks.

Independent UK editor Chloe Hubbard told an audience at Advertising Week in London that the new product “works commercially”.

“Just this week our Bulletin team created, in one day, a million article views,” Hubbard said. “That’s lucrative. That washes its face, right?”

Hubbard said the stories had been surfacing on Google Discover, the aggregation service that has been driving substantial traffic to some publishers over the last year, and chief executive Christian Broughton told Press Gazette that in some cases Bulletin stories had been beating their human-written counterparts on Google search.

Bulletin is currently only accessible through the Independent website, with a section of the homepage below the Lifestyle & Culture rail dedicated to the service. It will ultimately move onto a dedicated domain, Broughton said, with plans underway for an app and eventually audio briefings.

The AI rewrites are bylined to the same journalist who originally wrote the story and link through to the original version. Broughton said the same journalist edits both the original and Bulletin versions of a story.

A sample story about US tariffs from The Independent's Bulletin AI-written news summary service. The headline, above a picture of Donald Trump, says: Here’s everything you need to know about Trump’s tariffs on ‘Liberation Day’" It is followed by five bullet points, reading: "Former President Trump is poised to escalate the US trade war by imposing new tariffs on up to $3.3 trillion worth of imported goods. These tariffs, unveiled on Wednesday, target various sectors and countries, including those deemed to have "unfair taxes" on US goods or a trade surplus with the US. Canada, Mexico, and China, already subject to existing tariffs, are expected to be significantly impacted, facing potential cumulative tariffs across various goods. A new 25 per cent tariff on imported vehicles and parts will affect major automakers, including those manufacturing abroad and US companies reliant on imported parts. A 25 per cent levy on countries importing oil and gas from Venezuela, including the US, China, and India, further complicates the trade landscape. While the tariffs aim to boost domestic production, critics warn of increased costs for American consumers and potential retaliatory measures"
A sample story about US tariffs from The Independent’s Bulletin AI-written news summary service. Screenshot: Press Gazette

Independent’s Bulletin news service hopes to compete with Google AI Overviews

Hubbard said Bulletin came about because “lots of people want to read about things, but they don’t necessarily have the time to read 2,000 words…

“So we decided to look at how we might be able to give people our content – fully trusted, verified, fact-checked content – in a more condensed form that would potentially rival the summaries you may also see when you Google things, for instance. But we would know the source of truth for that content would be our own journalism.”

She added that a journalist checks the content before publication “to make sure that the AI hasn’t actually accidentally done something that isn’t right – which it doesn’t do, which is interesting”.

Hubbard said “we select the content based on what we think the audience might not have the time to go through”, with a greater focus on “chewier”, more difficult topics rather than celebrity stories or something intended to take time to read like a feature.

At time of writing, leading articles on the Bulletin page included AI-written summaries of stories about new US tariffs, a drop in Tesla sales and climate change. However there were also some articles on lighter subjects, some of them appearing under the “curiosity gap” headlines that often do well on Google Discover, for example “Jeremy Clarkson’s surprising weight loss snack after quitting Ozempic” and “Malcolm in the Middle star seen for first time in nearly 20 years”.

Hubbard said the Bulletin AI tool was “becoming a really good journalist”.

“Often we’re seeing the Bulletin version of the main Independent story will do better. The audience is preferring that one. So it’s like the AI is a very good journalist.”

Broughton said The Independent had briefly tried a similar idea using a human writer a decade ago. The i Paper, now part of DMGT, originally launched as a sister to The Independent with a similar focus on brevity and serving time-poor readers.

He dismissed any suggestion Bulletin might be used to reduce journalist numbers, pointing to the seven jobs The Independent says it has hired specifically to staff Bulletin. (One of these roles is taken up with Bulletin’s presence on WeAre8, a social media platform and partner for the news service.)

Broughton said: “If we just reduced down we’d kill The Independent. The Independent is only on a growth agenda.”

Email pged@pressgazette.co.uk to point out mistakes, provide story tips or send in a letter for publication on our "Letters Page" blog

Websites in our network