All Sections

View and post jobs in journalism
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Editor's Pick
  • Interviews
  • News
    • Broadcast Journalism
    • Digital Journalism
    • Magazines
    • Media Law
    • National Newspapers
    • People
      • Appointments
      • Obituaries
    • Regional Newspapers
  • Press Gazette Podcast
  • British Journalism Awards
  • Press Gazette Email Newsletter

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
  • Editorial standards
  • About/Contacts
  • Advertise/Partnerships
  • Privacy Policy
Close
[mashshare]
Skip to content
  • Editorial standards
  • About/Contacts
  • Advertise/Partnerships
  • Privacy Policy
All sections

Search

Search pressgazette.co.uk

Close

Press Gazette

Subscribe to our email newsletter Journalism email newsletter
  • News
  • Comment
  • Data
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Marketing
  • Awards
  • Jobs
  • Partners

Menu

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • National Newspapers
  • Regional Newspapers
  • Digital Journalism
  • Broadcast Journalism
  • Media Law
  • Magazines
  • Wires and Agencies
  • Obituaries
  • News
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Jobs
  • British Journalism Awards

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
Close
Piers Morgan scores first international TV interview with Donald Trump
Sky News not 'critical' to business, chief executive tells analysts
January 25, 2018
  • Digital Journalism
  •    
  • Media Business
  •    
  • National Newspapers
  •    
  • News
  •    
  • Social media
  •    

Facebook criticised over move to let users decide if sources 'trustworthy' in two-question survey

By James Walker Twitter

Share this

  • Tweet
  • Share 0
  • Reddit
Comments
0
Facebook's Australia news ban

Facebook’s  two-question survey to users asking whether a news source is trustworthy or not has been criticised for its reliance on the “wisdom of crowds”.

The social media giant announced its plan to launch the survey last week and put the decision on what is a trustworthy source in the hands of its community of users.

Timeline

  • March 5, 2021

    Robert Thomson: News Corp's Google deal will give journalism industry 'second wind'

  • March 4, 2021

    Google and Facebook's deals with publishers: What we know so far

  • March 4, 2021

    Why a fair licensing deal would see Google and Facebook pay news industry $2bn+ a year

The survey questions, revealed by Buzzfeed this week, are as follows:

Do you recognize the following websites?

  • Yes
  • No

How much do you trust each of these domains?

  • Entirely
  • A lot
  • Somewhat
  • Barely
  • Not at all

Press freedom campaign group Reporters without Borders (Reporters Sans Frontieres – RSF) has criticised Facebook over the changes.

The groups’ general secretary, Christophe Deloire, said: “Relying on the ‘wisdom of crowds’ to decide which news websites are trustworthy is illusory and can prove dangerous.

“You cannot use polling and belief as the basis for establishing facts. Journalism is an investigative process based on rigorous, fact-verification methods resulting in complete, reliable information that respects the truth.”

RSF also expressed scepticism about users being “objective judges” and concern about the survey potentially being manipulated by bad actors.

In announcing the new approach to trusted sources on Facebook last week, founder Mark Zuckerberg said in a blog post: “I’ve asked our product teams to make sure we prioritize news that is trustworthy, informative, and local.

“There’s too much sensationalism, misinformation and polarization in the world today. Social media enables people to spread information faster than ever before, and if we don’t specifically tackle these problems, then we end up amplifying them.

“That’s why it’s important that News Feed promotes high quality news that helps build a sense of common ground.”

Zuckerberg added that having the community of users determine which sources are “broadly trusted” would be the “most objective”.

Full Fact director Will Moy told Press Gazette he would welcome “more transparency” around the important changes, which will also see news content become less visible in the News Feed as part of a push for more “meaningful social interactions”.

Moy said: “Reputable surveys done by members of the British Polling Council publish details of timing, sample, methods, and questions used. We don’t have those here.

“Questions on trust will get different answers depending on what the people answering mean by ‘trust’.

“Do audiences trust outlets to be accurate – or do they trust them to be on their side? With a question so wide open to interpretation, Facebook will need to take care to avoid unintended consequences.”

Ipsos MORI chief executive Ben Page said on Twitter that the questions were not “especially biased” but added: “On trust you need to be specific – trust to do what…”

The trust survey has caused some to worry that smaller news publications would suffer as less survey respondents would recognise them and be able to define their trustworthiness.

In response to these fears, Facebook’s News Feed head Adam Mosseri wrote: “There are a lot of great niche specialist publications out there that only a small number of people know of, and this change won’t effect them one way or the other.”

He later explained that they would not be affected because “not enough people we survey will be familiar with small publishers for us to know if they’re trustworthy or not”.

Facebook has also recently revealed that it had made reporting “fake news” easier for users and that once its fact-checking partners had labelled a story as “false” it is able to “reduce further impressions” of the story on Facebook by 80 per cent.

Media mogul Rupert Murdoch has this week called on Facebook to pay “carriage fees” to trusted news sources.

Facebook declined to comment on criticism of its survey.

Picture: Reuters/Dado Ruvic

SIGN UP HERE FOR

MEDIA MONITOR

Press Gazette's weekly email providing strategic insight into the future of the media

Subscribe

Related Stories

  • Facebook ends experiment to take news out of users' News Feed after trial in six countries
  • News brands setting up Facebook 'page groups' in wake of platform move to demote news content
  • Facebook News Feed changes are a case of 'keep calm and carry on' says Trinity Mirror's digital director
  • News broadcasters boost Facebook Live video after change in web giant's algorithm

Explore these topics

  • Facebook
Browse, search and add journalism jobs
Comments
No comments to display

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More content

Post a job on Press Gazette

Most Popular

  1. Roy Greenslade IRA Roy Greenslade and IRA: Northern Ireland coverage scrutinised as Guardian apologises
  2. GB News briefing: Latest appointments news as channel gears up for launch
  3. Noel Fielding among 13 to settle News Group Newspapers phone hacking claims
  4. Meghan Mail appeal refused Mail on Sunday must publish front page statement on Meghan copyright win, judge rules
  5. Roy Greenslade Greenslade responds to outrage over IRA views: “I did nothing more than scores of journalists”

Latest Jobs

  • Editor (Maternity Cover), Place North West
  • Environment Impact Producer, The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
  • Global Health Impact Producer, The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
Sky News not 'critical' to business, chief executive tells analysts

© copyright 2021 Press Gazette Ltd. Made in Taiwan.