All Sections

View and post jobs in journalism
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Editor's Pick
  • Interviews
  • News
    • Broadcast Journalism
    • Digital Journalism
    • Magazines
    • Media Law
    • National Newspapers
    • People
      • Appointments
      • Obituaries
    • Regional Newspapers
  • Press Gazette Podcast
  • British Journalism Awards
  • Press Gazette Email Newsletter

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • RSS
Close
[mashshare]
Skip to content
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • RSS
All sections

Search

Search pressgazette.co.uk

Close

Press Gazette

Subscribe to our email newsletter Journalism email newsletter
  • News
  • Comment
  • Data
  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Marketing
  • Awards
  • Jobs

Menu

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • National Newspapers
  • Regional Newspapers
  • Digital Journalism
  • Broadcast Journalism
  • Media Law
  • Magazines
  • Wires and Agencies
  • Obituaries
  • News
  • Comment/Analysis
  • Jobs
  • British Journalism Awards

In the news

  • Platforms
  • Publishers
  • Interviews
  • Marketing
Close
PPA Publishing association urges chancellor to cut ‘digital reading tax’ in budget
'If you want to live, be quiet': Turkish newspaper publishes account of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi's 'murder'
October 17, 2018
  • Digital Journalism
  •    
  • News
  •    
  • Social media
  •    

Facebook accused of 'censorship' after deleting video on Christopher Columbus by Guardian journalist George Monbiot

By James Walker Twitter

Share this

  • Tweet
  • Share 0
  • Reddit
Comments
1
Picture: Double Down News

Facebook has been accused of censorship after it took down a video featuring Guardian columnist George Monbiot in which he criticised colonial explorer Christopher Columbus.

In the five-minute video, by Double Down News, Monbiot (pictured) also criticised the actions of later colonialists in America and India.

Timeline

  • December 17, 2020

    Facebook told Full Fact to remove fact-check ratings on doctored video of Keir Starmer during election

  • December 15, 2020

    Facebook News: US publishers happy with cash for content - but say project is a 'PR move'

  • December 3, 2020

    The News 50: Tech giants dwarf Rupert Murdoch to become the biggest news media companies in the English-speaking world

The video, which is still widely available on Youtube, is largely made up of archive and film footage that depicts some graphic violence and death.

Double Down News told Press Gazette the video had hit 900,000 views and reached an audience of 3m over eight days before it was taken down.

It claims that Facebook deleted the video due to a “violation of community standards”, but was given no specific reasons as to why it was taken down or a chance to appeal the decision.

A spokesperson for Double Down News said: “George recounts the horrors of history in vivid detail. Therefore, at times, we understand the film may have been uncomfortable for some to watch.

“A number of visuals used, taken from the film 1492 and historical documentary footage, were graphic in nature. Facebook could have opted to put a warning screen on the video, which we would have had no problem with.

“We fully understand the need for Facebook to monitor their platform for inappropriate content and fake news, especially in times like these, but the lack of transparency and recourse to appeal are deeply unsettling.

“Monbiot’s piece of video journalism was about the airbrushing of history – therefore there is a great irony in the fact it has now been airbrushed from their platform.”

Monbiot himself accused Facebook of “censorship” without an explanation or “right of appeal” in a series of tweets.

Double Down News, Facebook

Facebook community standards state that content glorifying violence is removed by the company, but that graphic content is allowed if it “raises awareness” about issues.

The social media giant has said that it will add a warning label to “especially graphic” content that does not merit being deleted.

Press Gazette has contacted Facebook for a statement on the decision, but has yet to receive a response.

Picture: Double Down News

SIGN UP HERE FOR

MEDIA MONITOR

Press Gazette's weekly email providing strategic insight into the future of the media

Subscribe

Related Stories

  • Cash for conspiracies: How David Icke, 'alternative' media and tech giants make money from coronavirus conspiracies
  • Facebook sorry for deleting video on Christopher Columbus by Guardian's George Monbiot amid call for 'transparent appeals system'
  • Tesla libel appeal against Top Gear over electric car review fails
  • ITV rapped over using 'IRA footage' from video game

Explore these topics

  • Facebook
  • Social Media
Browse, search and add journalism jobs
Comments

1 thought on “Facebook accused of 'censorship' after deleting video on Christopher Columbus by Guardian journalist George Monbiot”

  1. Paul Leeson says:
    October 18, 2018 at 11:36 am

    Was George foolish enough to think that the enormous rise in censorship across all major social networks wouldn’t apply to him ?

    Silly man, he might cheer less when someone critical of his opinions is censored.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More content

Post a job on Press Gazette

Most Popular

  1. PA wins High Court injunction against union issuing 'fake' press passes to 'citizen journalists'
  2. The new Trump bump: How Newsmax CEO Christopher Ruddy and far-right outlets are taking on Fox News
  3. Regional print journalist Liz Bates takes Channel 4 News political correspondent role
  4. GB News launch: Why advertisers are positive about new anchor-led news channel for UK
  5. Cash for conspiracies: How David Icke, 'alternative' media and tech giants make money from coronavirus conspiracies

Latest Jobs

  • Editor in Chief, Scottish Sun
  • Features Producer, Economist Radio
  • Editor, The Richard III Society
'If you want to live, be quiet': Turkish newspaper publishes account of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi's 'murder'

© copyright 2021 Press Gazette Ltd. Made in Taiwan.